Worked Example - Human Resolution

{
 "documentType": "human_resolution_packet",
 "schemaVersion": "0.1.0",
 "caseRef": {
 "caseId": "case-hypothetical-resolution-001"
 },
 "contractRef": {
 "contractId": "example-grounded-analysis",
 "contractVersion": "0.1.0",
 "contentHash": "sha256:c99c25a0a010f6e69774d0d7a187753a0cb328e8673a74b2b051fff44b1bf3a5"
 },
 "interaction": {
 "decisionTarget": "attempt",
 "request": {
 "requestId": "resolution-hypothetical-001",
 "triggerCriterionIds": [
 "C1-direct-response"
 ],
 "questionType": "instruction_precedence",
 "question": "A task-specific note says "Select yes or no," while the primary project instruction says not to force a binary conclusion when the evidence is inconclusive. Which instruction controls this case?",
 "contextFindingIds": [
 "F-hypothetical-conflict-001"
 ],
 "options": [
 {
 "optionId": "task-note-controls",
 "label": "The task-specific yes/no note controls",
 "effectSummary": "Evaluate directness using a binary-answer requirement."
 },
 {
 "optionId": "project-instruction-controls",
 "label": "The primary project instruction controls",
 "effectSummary": "Permit a calibrated inconclusive conclusion."
 },
 {
 "optionId": "contract-ambiguous",
 "label": "The project instruction is ambiguous",
 "effectSummary": "Escalate the case and create a contract issue."
 }
 ],
 "decisionChanging": true,
 "hideProvisionalDecision": true,
 "requiredExpertiseTags": [
 "project-owner"
 ],
 "status": "pending",
 "createdAt": "2026-07-15T13:00:00Z"
 }
 },
 "contextFindings": [
 {
 "findingId": "F-hypothetical-conflict-001",
 "findingType": "ambiguity",
 "criterionId": "C1-direct-response",
 "summary": "A task-specific binary-answer note appears to conflict with the primary project instruction.",
 "detail": "The precedence of the task note and project-level instruction is not defined for this hypothetical case.",
 "claimIds": [],
 "expectedElementIds": [],
 "targetSpans": [],
 "evidenceIds": [],
 "relationship": "insufficient",
 "materiality": "decisive",
 "severity": "major",
 "confidence": {
 "rawScore": 0.48,
 "band": "uncalibrated"
 },
 "status": "confirmed",
 "source": {
 "kind": "hybrid",
 "componentId": "ambiguity-detector-v1"
 }
 }
 ]
}